Research Paper Final Draft
Mr.Greenspan
EAP2 WW 052
Research Paper – Final Draft
May 4, 2005
Oil Pollution in Chechnya
Abstract
Chechnya is very critically polluted by oil and their environment has been damaged seriously for a long time. There are no fish in the river and people are suffering from disease. Also, the Russian government is pressuring Chechnya’s people. As a result, people are struggling to survive. There are several reasons for this problem – illegal oil extraction, producing low-quality oil, poor management of industrial equipments in Soviet times and the war between Russia and Chechnya. The Russian authorities pressure Chechnya’s people to control Chechnya again. For example, they pressure Chechnya’s refugees by switching off electricity and gas supplies. To solve this problem the Russia authorities has a program of cleaning up Chechnya, but this budget is inadequate. So how do they solve this problem? This paper offers a theory about what things should be done by the Russian government and how they could solve the oil pollution problem, and furthermore, what things should be done to guarantee the rights of human beings in Chechnya. The Russian government must offer more money for cleaning up Chechnya, change standards and regulations and protect people and environment.
Many places in the world have been suffering from pollution and Chechnya is a good example. Chechnya is located in south west of Russia and is considered a serious environmental disaster area. The first problem with oil pollution in Chechnya is that the ground and lands have been polluted critically for a long time. For example, people can pump oil simply into the lake using a container and the ground has been polluted seriously by petrol and oil products (Russian TV, 2004, para2). The second problem is that now there are no fish in the river, Sunzha, there is only oil in the river (para4). Russian TV mentions, “near the Sunzha there are tens of illegal mini oil-production plants,” and they pump out the oil without purification (para4). The last problem is that people are suffering from diseases. According to the republic’s Health Ministry, many children endure from bronchitis and the gas from oil products has caused “new form of diseases” (para9). Why do they have this serious oil pollution problem? There are several reasons for oil pollution. One is that people are illegally extract oil and produce low-quality oil to survive because people in Chechnya don’t have adequate conditions for living. The second reason is the poor management of industrial equipments in Sovie t times. Chechnya could not replace their industrial equipments because of the unfinished war between Russia and Chechnya. The last reason is the Russian government’s pressure and the war. Chechnya broke away from Russia in 1991, but the Russian government wants to control Chechnya again. However, Chechnya does not want Russia’s help; they want only to break away from Russia. To solve this problem, the Russia government has a program of cleaning up Chechnya with US $500,000. But experts argue that this budget is not enough to recover Chechnya (S. Blagov, 2003, para2). In my opinion, the government of Russia has to make some solutions for Chechnya’s oil pollution because such pollution has affected human beings and nature seriously and it can cause bigger environmental disaster in the future if the pollution is not solved by the government. I think what the government can do is giving a bigger budget for solving oil pollution, making laws about dumping oil and illegally extracting oil and strictly enforce them, providing people in the area of oil pollution better conditions of life and not to pressure Chechnya’s people.
To begin with, the Russian government should give more budgets for this oil pollution. As I stated in the introduction, the Russia government has a program of cleaning up Chechnya with US $500,000. But according to experts, this budget is not enough to clean up Chechnya. On this point, I think Russian authorities have to take action about it. For example, Russian authorities should ask for more money from the EU or some outside agencies because according to S.Blagov (2003), oil pollution damaged neighbor countries and environmental pollution is not only a problem for one country. If European countries do not do anything to solve the problems of Chechnya’s pollution, they also will face a similar environmental disaster as Chechnya. In addition, the Russian government should increase the budget for the cleaning program because most of oil pollution was caused by the war between Russia and Chechnya and needs of quick income. According to S.Balgov (2003), “the recent oil spills in Chechnya are a consequence of what they call the “Chechen bandit economy,” after 1991, when the Chechens declared independence, local warlords started splitting up the oil business in the region among themselves to make quick profits on illegal extraction” (para8). “Much of the Chechen oil sector’s infrastructure was badly damaged in the subsequent war”(para9). The Russian government and European nations must remain it in their memory; ‘fix it before it breaks’.
Second, the government should change their environmental standards and regulations. According to Ria Novosti (Dec 20, 2004), “the environment protection system has no openness at all” (para2). In addition, the Russian TV states, “the tens of illegal oil-production factories which do not observe any health regulations are to blame” (Oct 23, 2004, para1). In this situation, I think the government must control their companies very strictly because most companies are not spending much money for cleaning industrial wastes that causes environment pollution critically. For example, by making standards and regulations about dumping oil and illegally extracting oil, and penalties and rewards such as big fines for polluters and opportunities of investment, the government has to encourage their companies to protect their environment.
Third, the Russian government should provide people better conditions of life to people and companies. People have been suffering from disease such as tuberculosis, viral disease (hepatitis A), intestinal infections, bronchitis and other new form of diseases, for a long time. According to S.Blagov (2003), “following years of war and continued armed hostilities, the Chechen population became largely dependent on illegal oil extraction to survive” (para6). S.Isayev also states in the article that “Chechnya ecological situation dramatically affects birth rate” and “only six out of ten newborn infants on an average survive” (para2). Moreover, according to the Russian TV (2004), lots of children endure from bronchitis and the gas from oil products has caused “new form of diseases” (para9). The government of Russia should move to protect Chechnya’s people from such critical situations as serious pollution that affects human beings hazardously. For example, first the government should ask for not to extract “low-quality oil” by offering better conditions of life. Second, the government has to ask for outside agencies for cleaning equipment to help clean up. Third, the government must replace their industrial equipments that spill out oil into the river and ground. Fourth, the government has to educate people and companies how the influences of low-quality oil have polluted their ground and rivers, affected badly on their health. Lastly, the government should encourage industrial companies to filter the pollutants and wall up leak of the oil by supporting the new industrial equipment. I believe that it is going to reduce oil pollution increasingly and oil pollution problem can be gradually solved. Moreover, if the Russian government provides better welfare services to Chechnya’s people, this critical situation will be reduced. But the problem is the Russian government is not going to do that because of political and economic reason, and the government of Chechnya is not developed enough and doesn’t have adequate money and time for doing that.
Finally, the Russian government should not pressure Chechnya’s people and infringe their human rights. After the collapse of the Soviet Union, Chechnya declared its independence from Russia in 1991, but Russia didn’t want to lose more their area, especially the land of oil; Chechnya (C.Ingold. June, 2002. para6). As a result, Russia army moved into Chechnya and managed it. According to S.Blagov (2003), they pressure Chechen refugees to move from refugee camps into Chechnya by “switch off electricity and gas supplies” (para16). In this situation, the Russian government should solve this problem in other ways, for example, by providing Chechen’s people better conditions to live, Russian authorities make them to move spontaneously into Chechnya. If Russian authorities give constantly Chechen’s refugees such pressures, UN and Human Rights Organizations should restrain and manage their inhuman behaviors. The most difficult problem is that we should make Russia agree to this because Russia doesn’t want to lose Chechnya.
In conclusion, the war between Russia and Chechnya made this oil pollution critically, but they should solve this problem to protect Chechen people. While nature and human beings of one nation have suffered from environmental disaster and war for a long time, if the government of the nation does not take a action about it, it means the duty of the government is going the wrong way as everybody know. What can solve the problem of one nation is only the government of the nation. As I described before, the government should offer more money, change standards and regulations, provide people better conditions of life and not pressure Chechnya’s people. In other words, the government should guarantee the rights of human beings in Chechnya. If the Russian government continues to pressure Chechnya’s people and don’t finish the war, UN and outside agencies should restrain and stop their inhuman behavior and the war in Chechnya. Otherwise, they will face a more critical environmental disaster. They must remain it in their memory; ‘fix it before it breaks.’
Bibliography
Russian TV report (Oct 23, 2004). Oil Pollution in Chechnya reaches critical levels. Lexis-Nexis. Retrieved Apr, 1, 2005 from: http://web.lexis-nexis.com/universe/document?_m=4a0ffaa29e50d5ea90a310b31d6c812d&_docnum=1&wchp=dGLbVlz-zSkVb&_md5=158f8a8f4438e519fb5ff32834fcd0ce
Blagov, Sergei. (Jan 03, 2003). Environmental disaster in the making. Asia Times. Retrieved Apr 8, 2005, from Johnson’s Russia List, http://www.cdi.org/russia/johnson/7003-13.cfm
Novosti, Ria. (Dec 20, 2004). 90% of Russian industry enterprises have no ecological programs. Lexis-Nexis. Retrieved Apr 13, 2005 from: http://web.lexis-nexis.com/universe/printdoc
Isayev, Said. (Nov 4, 2004). Ecological situation dramatically affects birth rate. Lexis-Nexis. Retrieved Apr 29, 2005 from: http://web.lexis-nexis.com/universe/document?_m=efd12017b2494e70a7b33f159ee6d19d&_docnum=1&wchp=dGLbVtb-zSkVb&_md5=5c20c57227eccab1ce6447a4339e17a4
Ingold, Christopher. (June, 2002). Chechnya Conflict and Environmental Implications. The Inventory of Conflict & Environment. Retrieved Mar 28, 2005 from: http://www.american.edu/ted/ice/chechnya.htm
Energy Information Administration (EIA). (May, 2004). Russia: Environmental Issues. Energy Information Administration (EIA). Retrieved Mar 28, 2005 from: http://www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/cabs/russenv.html
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). (Dec, 2004). Understanding Oil Spills And Oil Spill Response. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Retrieved Apr 28, 2005 from: http://www.epa.gov/oilspill/pdfbook.htm











